Private Equity: Overvalued and Overrated?

American Affairs

Article

16 Pages

American Affairs argues that private equity’s reputation for superior returns is overstated, challenging the narrative that it consistently outperforms public markets. It highlights how fee structures and selective reporting can distort results, with some analyses suggesting public equities match or exceed returns after costs.

Key Takeaways

Fee Drag Matters: Typical “2 and 20” fees can reduce investor net returns by 3–5% annually, significantly eroding headline performance advantages.
Benchmark Comparison Gap: Studies show private equity underperforms small-cap public equities by roughly 1–2% per year when adjusted for leverage and risk.
IRR Distortion Effects: Internal rate of return metrics can overstate performance by 300–500 basis points due to timing assumptions and cash flow manipulation.

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Related Content

Alternative Assets
Nov 2026
Scroll to Top