Gotham Asset Management examines why valuation driven investing periodically underperforms despite strong long term logic. The paper argues speculative growth stocks, index concentration, and investor impatience distorted 2015 returns, while 25 years of research suggest valuation spreads historically normalize within roughly two years.
2016 Outlook: Same Simple Secret to Long-Term Investment Success
Gotham Asset Management
Research
4 Pages
Key Takeaways
Valuation Reversion Timing: Gotham’s research found valuation weighted indexes reached expected return levels within two years in 95% of observations across the past 25 years.
Speculative Stocks Favored: Gotham’s leveraged long portfolio fell 5.6% in 2015, while speculative short positions rose 1.7% as investors favored momentum and growth narratives.
Patience Often Rewarded: Among top quartile managers, 96% experienced at least one three year stretch in the bottom half of performance rankings during a recent decade.