The Dispersion Delusion

Verdad

Research

8 Pages

Chingono and Rasmussen challenge the notion that private equity’s wide performance dispersion reflects persistent manager skill. They demonstrate that concentration, leverage, and small-cap bias in PE portfolios can replicate this dispersion in public markets—implying fees and portfolio structure—not skill, may explain the gap.

“Our results suggest that the dispersion in private equity can be fully replicated in public markets, provided that investors focus on buying cheap, levered micro-caps and hold them in a concentrated portfolio, similar to the portfolio construction in PE.”

Key Takeaways

Dispersion driven by structure: A 20-position, levered micro-cap public portfolio produces return dispersion nearly matching private equity—suggesting structure, not skill, drives variance
Fees erode net performance: Simulated micro-cap returns align with PE before fees—but net returns lag by ~2–4% annually due to PE fee drag
Manager selection may not add value: Limited persistence among top-quartile PE funds implies outperformance is more random than skill-based

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Related Content

Alternative Assets
Nov 2026
Scroll to Top