Research Affiliates examines how rising valuations may distort the historical success of smart beta strategies and factor investing. The paper argues many popular approaches now trade above historical norms, suggesting weaker forward returns, while currently unpopular value strategies appear comparatively inexpensive despite years of underperformance.
To Win With “Smart Beta” Ask If the Price Is Right
Research Affiliates
Rob Arnott
Research
19 Pages
Key Takeaways
Valuations Drive Returns: Across 192 tests, not one factor showed the “wrong” sign between starting valuation and future returns, reinforcing the paper’s argument that cheaper strategies historically outperform.
Value Looks Cheap: Value’s relative valuation reached 0.13 in March 2016, placing it in the bottom historical decile and implying potential outperformance versus growth nearing 8% annually over five years.
Crowded Trades Matter: Low volatility strategies traded near the top valuation decile historically, while Fundamental Index strategies sat near the bottom quintile, highlighting how investor crowding may reshape future factor performance.