S&P Dow Jones Indices examines shareholder yield, which combines dividends, net buybacks and net debt reduction, as a broader gauge of how companies return capital than dividends alone. The authors pair it with capital return growth, profitability and balance sheet strength, finding the combination showed lower downside capture than the S&P 500 in back tests.
A Framework for Identifying Companies With Resilient Shareholder Yield Profiles
S&P Global
Elizabeth Bebb, Rupert Watts
Research
18 Pages
Key Takeaways
Buybacks Lead Capital Return: S&P 500 buybacks reached roughly $990 billion in 2025, well above the roughly $710 billion paid out in dividends that year.
Back Tested Outperformance: From June 2000 to May 2026 the index returned 11.21% annualized in back tests, beating the S&P 500 by 2.67% a year.
Smaller Downside Capture: The index captured 94.79% of S&P 500 upside but only 78.52% of its downside over the full back tested period.