More Logical Four-factor Model of Stock Returns?

CXO Advisory

Research

2 Pages

CXO Advisory discusses research proposing a new four factor stock return model that replaces book to market and momentum with investment and return on equity factors. The paper argues the revised framework better explains several well known anomalies across 1972 to 2011, challenging long established factor models.

Key Takeaways

New Factors Proposed: The investment factor earned 0.44% average monthly returns and the ROE factor earned 0.60%, replacing book to market and momentum in the proposed framework.
Better Anomaly Coverage: The model outperformed the Carhart four factor model in explaining 5 major anomalies, including earnings surprise, financial distress, idiosyncratic volatility, net stock issuance, and composite issuance.
Theory Over Data: Evidence from 1972 to 2011 suggests the stronger theoretical foundation of investment and ROE factors could make their explanatory power more durable than legacy factor models.

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Related Content

Asset Allocation
Nov 2026
Scroll to Top