Cambria Investment Management examines why public pension funds relying on 8% return assumptions may underestimate long term funding risks. It argues that unrealistic expectations encourage greater portfolio risk, while Japan’s experience suggests 0% returns over decades deserve serious stress testing consideration today.
What if 8% is Really 0%? Pension Funds Investing with Fingers-Crossed and Eyes Closed
Cambria Investments
Meb Faber
Research
9 Pages
Key Takeaways
Funding Reality: Reducing assumed returns from 8% to about 4% can increase California pension unfunded liabilities nearly 700%, from $55.4 billion to $425.2 billion.
Risk Chasing: A traditional 60/40 allocation requires equities to earn about 11% to achieve an overall 8% portfolio return, encouraging greater exposure to risky assets.
Japan's Lesson: Japan's endowment style portfolio returned only 1.42% over two decades, while Japanese government bonds earned 4.36% annually and equities lost 4.62% per year.