Research Affiliates examines why the largest companies often become difficult investments despite outstanding businesses. The paper argues that market leaders frequently face slower growth, richer valuations, and greater competitive and regulatory pressures. Historical evidence suggests these firms have often lagged peers after reaching the top.
The Winners Curse: Too Big to Succeed?
Research Affiliates
Rob Arnott, Lillian Wu
Research
18 Pages
Key Takeaways
Top Dogs Lag: U.S. sector leaders underperformed their sectors by 3.2% annually over the following 10 years, with only 33% outperforming their peers across that period.
Global Pattern Persists: Across 9 developed markets, sector leaders underperformed by 4.3% annually over 10 years, and every country in the sample exhibited the same directional result.
Expectations Matter: In the U.S., 414 of 707 one year observations saw the largest company trail its sector, highlighting how elevated expectations can become difficult to exceed.