Research Affiliates explores whether random pricing noise alone can explain the long observed size and value premiums. The paper argues that even modest mispricing can produce return patterns resembling historical evidence, challenging purely risk based explanations. It suggests just 10% noise variance can closely replicate classic Fama French results.
Can Noise Create Size and Value Effects?
Research Affiliates
Rob Arnott, Jason Hsu
Research
32 Pages
Key Takeaways
Noise Drives Premiums: A model with just 10% noise variance relative to total return variance closely matches the size and value return patterns documented by Fama and French.
Small Stocks Benefit: Expected annual returns range from 13.78% for Small ME stocks to 9.18% for Large ME stocks, consistent with the model's pricing noise framework.
Risk Alone Falls Short: Smallest decile stocks generate 1.67% alpha while largest decile stocks show negative 1.18% alpha, suggesting beta differences explain little of the observed premium.