The authors revisit the long debated size factor and argue its weak historical record largely disappears once firm quality, or “junk,” is controlled for. Rather than dismissing small caps, the paper suggests many criticisms stem from mixing high quality and low quality companies, revealing a stronger and more consistent size premium across markets and time.
Size Matters, if You Control Your Junk
AQR
Cliff Asness, Andrea Frazzini
Research
32 Pages
Key Takeaways
Quality Changes Everything: Controlling for quality increases SMB alpha from 14 bps to 49 bps per month, with the t statistic rising to 4.89, making the size effect far more statistically robust.
Global Evidence Strengthens: Across 24 markets, 23 showed higher SMB alpha after controlling for quality, while international SMB alpha increased from 11 bps to 29 bps using quality controls.
Seasonality Becomes Smaller: Outside January, the size premium improves from negative 0.04% to positive 0.38% per month after controlling for quality, reducing reliance on the January effect.