This paper is Part I in a series from Antti Ilmanen, which tries to understand how investors actually form long-run return expectations. He contrasts “objective” yield-based expected returns and “subjective” rearview-mirror expectations and argues that “rearview-mirror expectations have made many investors too optimistic on risky and private assets after the good times following the Global Financial Crisis, and too cautious on liquid diversifiers.
How Do Investors Form Long-Run Return Expectations?
AQR
Antti Ilmanen
Research
16 Pages
Key Takeaways
Subjective expectations are procyclical: Investors tend to be overly optimistic after bull markets and pessimistic after downturns, contrary to objective indicators.
Objective models offer better guidance: Yield-based measures, like cyclically adjusted earnings yields, provide more reliable long-term return forecasts.
Rearview-mirror thinking is risky: Relying on past performance can lead to overexposure to overvalued assets and underinvestment in undervalued opportunities.