Essentia Analytics explores why investors often refuse to repurchase stocks they previously sold at a loss, even when fundamentals improve. The paper argues that “repurchase bias” shrinks the investable universe and can weaken long-term decision-making, while advocating a disciplined review process that removes emotion from re-entry decisions.
Once Bitten: Why Investors Won’t Buy Back a Stock That Burned Them
Essentia Analytics
Clare Flynn Levy
Research
7 Pages
Key Takeaways
Repurchase bias: A study of more than 660,000 investors found they were 50% to 67% more likely to repurchase stocks previously sold for gains than losses.
Professionals affected: Mutual fund managers were roughly 20% less likely to repurchase stocks they had previously sold at a loss, even after changing firms.
Process over instinct: Essentia notes that most skilled fund managers have hit rates below 50%, making systematic reviews of exited positions essential for identifying renewed opportunities.