CXO Advisory examines whether changes in large cap market concentration can help predict future stock market returns through a simple rules based strategy. The findings suggest the signal showed historical promise, though data limitations and testing bias raise important questions about how dependable the relationship may prove.
Simple Market Capitalization Concentration Trading Strategy
CXO Advisory
Research
6 Pages
Key Takeaways
Predictive Signal: Lagged annual changes in the S&P 500 to Russell 2000 ratio explained about 8% of next quarter S&P 500 return variation, with a 0.28 Pearson correlation.
Trading Edge: Using an optimal -2.5% threshold, the strategy outperformed buy and hold across thresholds from -12.5% to 5.0% while requiring only 39 switches.
Practical Limits: The optimal strategy tolerated up to 1.7% trading friction per switch, but the relatively short sample from 1987 to 2012 increases uncertainty around future effectiveness.