This report examines how public companies manage equity issuance and buybacks, highlighting the importance of aligning actions with intrinsic value. Firms engaging in both simultaneously may undermine shareholder returns if price and value diverge.
Michael Mauboussin researches companies that both issue and retire shares around the same time, finding that companies with low stock-based compensation issuance and high buybacks delivered the highest average and median total shareholder return. Mauboussin starts off his podcast with Meb on this topic.