Cliff Asness follows up on AQR’s recent piece, which was critical of options-based strategies such as “defined outcome funds” and “buffered ETFs”. He addresses the six main criticisms of the original piece and offers a theory for why an industry that lacks compelling data and economic rationale to support it still has diehard fans.
Buffer Madness
AQR
Cliff Asness, Daniel Villalon
Research
10 Pages
Key Takeaways
Underperformance is widespread: 86% of analyzed funds had lower returns than a stock/cash benchmark, with 70% also experiencing worse drawdowns.
Defined outcome funds offer poor trade-offs: Even among those with better drawdowns, the average benefit was a mere 0.7% improvement, offset by a 7.3% reduction in cumulative returns.
Behavioral biases sustain popularity: The appeal of these strategies persists due to investor psychology, despite lacking empirical support.