Buffer Madness

AQR

Research

10 Pages

Cliff Asness follows up on AQR’s recent piece, which was critical of options-based strategies such as “defined outcome funds” and “buffered ETFs”. He addresses the six main criticisms of the original piece and offers a theory for why an industry that lacks compelling data and economic rationale to support it still has diehard fans.

Key Takeaways

Underperformance is widespread: 86% of analyzed funds had lower returns than a stock/cash benchmark, with 70% also experiencing worse drawdowns.
Defined outcome funds offer poor trade-offs: Even among those with better drawdowns, the average benefit was a mere 0.7% improvement, offset by a 7.3% reduction in cumulative returns.
Behavioral biases sustain popularity: The appeal of these strategies persists due to investor psychology, despite lacking empirical support.

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Related Content

Asset Allocation
Nov 2026
Scroll to Top