Rob Arnott revisits Benjamin Graham’s Mr. Market to explain why a low valuation ratio alone can lead investors into value traps. Using four pairs of stocks, including oil refiners, tech manufacturers and two famous financial names, he shows how combining value, quality and momentum signals helps separate genuine bargains from cheap stocks where the market has read the footnotes.
Value Traps Are Painful … Read the Footnotes
Syzygy Asset Management
Rob Arnott
Research
15 Pages
Key Takeaways
Value Funds Diverged Widely: Large value fund leaders gained 26% to 48% this year through September, while laggards ranged from a 2% loss to a 4% gain.
Refiners Earned Their Weight: Marathon and Valero ranked in the 99th and 98th percentiles on combined score, then gained 146% and 142% through September 2026.
Famous Names Stayed Out: Skipping Berkshire Hathaway and JPMorgan, benchmark heavyweights with 16x P/E ratios, added 1.10 percentage points of excess return as the index rose 19.27%.