Do Financial Markets Reward Buying or Selling Insurance and Lottery Tickets?

AQR

Article

1 Pages

AQR examines whether investors are better rewarded for buying or selling investments with insurance and lottery like payoffs. It argues market preferences often overprice positive skewness, leaving sellers of catastrophe insurance and speculative lottery exposures with stronger long run expected rewards than buyers.

Key Takeaways

Insurance Premiums: Selling S&P 500 volatility historically benefited from a persistent implied versus realized volatility gap from 1986 to 2012, while buying protection was typically more expensive over time.
Lottery Discount: Long positions in the two nearest VIX futures lost 28% annually from December 2005 through August 2011, illustrating the long run cost of buying volatility exposure.
Tail Risk Evidence: Stocks with high downside betas outperformed by 6 percentage points annually, supporting the idea that bearing systematic tail risk has historically earned higher compensation.

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Scroll to Top