The authors examine whether weighting equity indexes by company fundamentals instead of market capitalization can improve long term portfolio characteristics. They argue fundamental measures like sales, cash flow, and book value may better represent economic size, challenging conventional index construction while raising questions about efficiency.
Fundamental Indexation
Research Affiliates
Rob Arnott, Jason Hsu
Research
35 Pages
Key Takeaways
Fundamental Weighting Benefits: Fundamental indexes outperformed the reference capitalization index by an average of 2.13% annually across 42 years while maintaining similar beta, volatility, and low turnover.
Bear Market Strength: Fundamental indexes outperformed by 6.73% annually during bear markets and added 3.38% annually in recessions, suggesting results extended across multiple market environments.
Low Trading Friction: Average turnover was 13.1% versus 6.3% for the capitalization weighted benchmark, and excess returns remained 1.99% after assuming 1% transaction costs each way.