Cambria Investment Management explores how combining value and momentum stock selection with simple market hedging can improve long term investing. The paper argues disciplined offense and defense preserved much of the return advantage while historically cutting drawdowns nearly in half, challenging pure buy and hold.
Learning to Play Offense and Defense: Combining Value and Momentum from the Bottom Up, and the Top Down
Cambria Investments
Meb Faber
Research
10 Pages
Key Takeaways
Value Momentum Edge: A value and momentum portfolio returned 16.68% annually versus 9.98% for the S&P 500 from 1964 to 2014, though maximum drawdown reached 56.05%.
Hedging Reduced Risk: Adding valuation and trend based hedges lowered maximum drawdown from 56.05% to 27.12% while maintaining a 15.59% annual return and improving the Sharpe ratio to 0.74.
Behavior Matters: Dalbar found investors earned only 5.19% annually versus the S&P 500's 9.85% over 20 years, highlighting how large drawdowns often drive poor investment decisions.