Research Affiliates examines whether the biggest U.S. stocks deserve their valuation premium or simply benefit from index membership. The paper argues the Next 500 grew cash flow faster than the top 500 over 35 years, yet large caps kept up largely through multiple expansion and passive-flow reinforcement.
Membership Has Its Privileges: Who Pays the Premium?(CFA Institute Research Foundation Series)
Research Affiliates
Rob Arnott
Research
9 Pages
Key Takeaways
Cash flow gap: The Next 500 compounded operating cash flow near 9% annually, versus roughly 6.5% for the largest-cap cohort.
Premium widened: The largest-cap cohort’s valuation premium averaged 17% over 35 years and reached 80% versus the Next 500 by mid-2025.
Indexing loop: Indexing rose from 3% of U.S. market cap in 1990 to over 50% by 2025, reinforcing cap-weighted winners.