Nixed: The Upside of Getting Dumped

Research Affiliates

Research

11 Pages

This paper examines the long-term performance of stocks deleted from major cap-weighted indexes, finding that such “nixed” companies tend to outperform post-removal due to mean reversion and liquidity-driven mispricing. The authors suggest that a disciplined strategy focused on these deletions can uncover overlooked value, particularly when growth fades and small-cap/value cycles turn.

Rob Arnott demonstrates index deletions have historically beaten the Russell 2000 Value Index in ‘spectacular fashion.’ He dives into the reasons why and explains Research Affiliates’ new strategy based on this.

Key Takeaways

Deletion rebound: Dumped stocks lag prior to removal but have outperformed by over 5% annually for five years post-deletion
Structural inefficiencies: Index reconstitutions trigger forced selling and mispricing, creating a favorable setup for long-term investors
Value rotation potential: A deletions portfolio may shine if the current growth regime gives way to small-cap or value leadership

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Scroll to Top