The Long Run Drivers of Stock Returns: Total Payouts and the Real Economy

Research

31 Pages

Roger Ibbotson examines how stock returns are ultimately tied to total payouts and economic productivity rather than valuation changes alone. The paper challenges conventional dividend-only thinking by arguing buybacks materially reshape return expectations, while showing payout growth has historically tracked GDP and productivity surprisingly closely.

Key Takeaways

Buybacks Changed Payout Math: Following the 1982 SEC buyback ruling, total yield reached 4.89% from 1871 to 2014, exceeding the traditional 4.50% dividend yield.
Valuation Impact Minimal: From 1871 to 2014, changes in price-to-total-payout ratios contributed just 0.20% annually to total returns versus 2.05% payout growth.
Economic Growth Connection: Historical equity returns reached 9.05% annually from 1871 to 2014, with aggregate payout growth closely matching GDP and productivity growth over time.

Join our newsletter to have all of this content + Exclusive Newsletter Bonus Content delivered to your inbox every week

Scroll to Top