S&P Dow Jones Indices examines whether active fund outperformance tends to persist or fade. Only 4.5% of above median large cap active equity funds stayed above median through 2025, below the 6.25% rate expected from randomness.
U.S. Persistence Scorecard
S&P Global
Anu Ganti
Research
16 Pages
Key Takeaways
Persistence Looks Fleeting: Among large cap funds above median in 2021, only 4.5% stayed above median through 2025, below the random expectation of 6.25%.
Short Term Improved: Top quartile large cap funds from 2023 showed 29% persistence over two years, up from 0% in the prior scorecard.
Weak Funds Disappear: Among fourth quartile domestic U.S. equity funds, 23% merged or liquidated within five years, compared with 10% for top quartile funds.